Belonging Isn’t a Metric—It’s the Work: Reflections on a Journey in Community Building
“Thank you for making us feel like we belong here.”
I’ve heard this whispered by parents in hallways, written in thank-you notes, and shared in reflection circles with colleagues and volunteer mentors. This simple phrase may not appear in grant reports or have a measurable ROI, but it has become my North Star. Because when someone says they feel that they belong, that’s when you know you’ve truly built community.
And yet, in the nonprofit and education worlds where I’ve spent my 25-year career, “community” is often used as a buzzword, measured in metrics, or folded into branding language. But building a thriving community isn’t casual. It isn’t quick. And it certainly isn’t one-sided.
Community is not a product. It’s not a checkbox on a logic model.
It’s a practice. A way of being.
And it cannot be constructed for others.
It must be built with them—through relationship, trust, and co-creation.
What I’ve Learned About Community
1. Community Is Built Through Shared Identity—and Shared Complexity
I was born into a large Swedish, Irish, Ojibwa, and Lakota family on the East Side of St. Paul. My early life was shaped by contrasts—holiday dinners of fish and frybread, Swedish Institute festivals, and Native American powwows, the languages of love, laughter, and belonging. Growing up in a multiethnic family and community—and becoming a multilingual woman—I learned to navigate both visibility and erasure. Belonging was never guaranteed. It was earned through presence, participation, and persistence.
Learning Spanish as a teenager and Japanese as an adult, and traveling through Mexico, Central and South America, and Asia, I discovered that language wasn’t just a tool—it was a bridge. My chosen path as a bilingual educator, interpreter, and community builder became a commitment to creating spaces where all are welcomed, valued, and brought into belonging.
When my students and their families entered one of my classrooms, they knew who I thought they were, how I felt about them, and what I expected—because I was clear on who I was and what I expected of myself. We didn’t always get it right, but we built what our community needed to grow and thrive.
2. Community Is Co-Created, Not Delivered
I spent over two decades in education—teaching everything from kindergarten Spanish immersion to middle school dual-language programs, from shelter schools for unaccompanied minors to freedom schools for African American youth. I learned early on that no curriculum could replace co-creation with students and families.
That same lesson has shaped my work at Entrepreneurship for All (EforAll), where I support early-stage entrepreneurs from underrepresented communities. In a space often dominated by gatekeeping and scarcity, we’ve built a network of bilingual volunteers, mentors, and partners who champion inclusive entrepreneurship.
One moment stands out: a volunteer mentor—initially unsure if they had anything to offer, given they weren’t an entrepreneur—told me, “This space feels different. People show up like they mean it.” That’s belonging in action. We don’t just run programs—we build relationships. And we’re building them with care.
3. Programs That Exclude Voices Cannot Build Belonging
In both education and nonprofit spaces, I’ve seen the harm that comes from “building for” instead of “with.” I’ve sat in rooms where well-funded programs were designed without ever involving the people they were meant to serve. In some cases, communities were only invited in after the decisions were made—and only for the photo ops.
Even the most well-intentioned efforts can feel extractive when they prioritize control over collaboration. When engagement is transactional—when input is treated as formality, not guidance—we lose the chance to build something lasting.
Community isn’t a grant requirement. It’s a relationship. And if we want that relationship to be authentic, we have to build it together from the start.
4. Belonging Is the Strongest Indicator of Sustainable Change
Belonging Isn’t a Metric—It’s the Work:
Reflections on a Journey in Community Building, by Nicole Saice
When I transitioned into nonprofit work, I brought my classroom values with me. Whether supporting entrepreneurs, facilitating mentorship, or designing inclusive programming, I’ve learned that metrics rarely tell the whole story.
What I pay closest attention to is often invisible:
● Who feels safe speaking in their first language?
● Who feels seen and heard in meetings and circles?
● Who sees themselves and their values reflected in leadership and decisions?
At EforAll, we ask these questions constantly. Because a program that doesn’t make room for people to bring their full selves isn’t one that fosters growth. Belonging is not a soft metric—it’s the foundation of sustainable change.
5. Building Across Systems Requires Relationships, Not Just Roles
Throughout my life, I’ve worn many hats—educator, coach, interpreter, project manager, and co-founder. But whether planning a school curriculum, launching a nonprofit initiative, or co-hosting a cultural event, the thread that connects it all is relationship.
People often describe me as a collaborator, connector, and communicator. These aren’t just soft skills—they’re survival skills in systems that often overlook lived experience. I’ve spent my life learning how to hold space, listen deeply, and bridge divides—and I believe that’s how we move forward.
The joy of building community across places and roles wasn’t just about sharing food or cultural traditions—it was about bringing people together across language, history, and experience. It was about collaboration, co-creation, and care.
Whether you’re in a classroom, a nonprofit, or a boardroom, building community starts with:
● Listening before acting
● Honoring lived experience as expertise
● Creating shared ownership from day one
● Prioritizing relationships over results
This work isn’t always easy or visible, but don’t stop looking—because it’s always worth it.
Belonging Isn’t a Metric—It’s the Work:
Reflections on a Journey in Community Building, by Nicole Saice
An Invitation to Build Communities
For a long time, I worried that my approach—grounded in empathy, trust, and cultural fluency—might seem too “soft” for spaces obsessed with speed and scale. But I’ve come to see that my tenderness, my story, and my community care—that is the work.
To my fellow educators, nonprofit professionals, and community builders:
Don’t just build programs. Build belonging.
Let’s pause and ask:
● Who is shaping this [community] space—and who isn’t?
● What assumptions are we making about what people need or want?
● Are we making decisions with communities, or just about them?
● Are we embedding trust, care, and shared power into the way we work?
Every community is unique. It carries its wisdom, wounds, and ways of working. And it deserves more than a one-size-fits-all solution.
Let’s build with intention.
Let’s build with humility.
Let’s build together.
Join The Nonprofit Hive community for insightful discussions and valuable connections. Share your own experiences and insights or sign up for an upcoming Hive Chat to connect with others. Together, we can be stronger and prepared for anything! Join today 🐝
With 25 years of experience in education, entrepreneurship, and community building, Nicole Saice brings heart, creativity, and strategy to every project she leads. A multiethnic, multilingual woman,she designs inclusive spaces where people feel seen, heard, and empowered, and she thrives at bringing people together to turn big ideas into meaningful action. Whether organizing community events, supporting small business owners, or driving volunteer engagement, Nicole blends empathy with execution to spark real, lasting change.